My take-aways from the book “Finding Fertile Ground” by Scott Shane

Scott A. Shane’s excellent book focuses on technology entrepreneurs – no discussions of starting your own hair salon or sushi restaurant here. He offers valuable, if not original, insights on business start-ups, hiring, finance, suppliers and especially customer service in this rundown of problems that commonly beset new ventures.

Entrepreneurs, common wisdom says, are hard driving, charismatic and visionary. Shane turns sharply away from this “entrepreneurial cult of personality,” and presents a strong case that what really counts is picking the right industry to enter in the first place, and then proceeding correctly.

The next time you walk through a crowd, consider this: four out of every 100 people you pass are starting their own companies. In fact, business owners are 13% of the nonagricultural work force in the U.S. Being an entrepreneur, it seems, is as American as apple pie.

The good news is that more new organizations are being formed in the U.S. than ever before. The bad news is that most of them will fail, four out of 10 in their first year. Only one in four will survive eight years, and most of the owners will make less than they would working for someone else.

“No book discussed high technology entrepreneurship in a way that showed people how to identify a business opportunity to exploit a new technology successfully.”

If you hope to be a long-term entrepreneur, perhaps the most important decision you will make is what industry to enter. Restaurants and retail businesses experience a very high incidence of failure, but companies that specialize in technology-related fields have a much greater chance of success.

“This book identifies the key difference between the successes and the masses – the selection of the right business concept to exploit a valuable opportunity.”

Ten Commandments of Entrepreneurial Entry

Entrepreneurs considering a start-up in a high tech field should heed these 10 rules:

Rule No. 1: “Select the Right Industry”

The first rule of success for starting a new business is choosing the right industry. New firms do far better in some industries than others. Industries have four traits that determine how well a new company is likely to perform once inside the fold. They are:

“So, where do these opportunities come from? What form do they take? How do successful entrepreneurs match opportunities to innovation? How do successful entrepreneurs identify these opportunities?”

  1. “Knowledge conditions” – Several knowledge factors determine an industry’s receptivity to new entrepreneurs. If a production process is highly complex – the manufacture of aerospace products, for example – conditions are less favorable for a new firm.
  2. “Demand conditions” – What do consumers seek? How do their wishes translate into their demands of your business? Demand conditions influence an entrepreneur’s success in any industry. Choose an industry with substantial consumer demand. A large market gives you a better chance, because greater demand leads to faster earnings.
  3. “Stage of the industry life cycle” – Young industries are more open to entrepreneurial upstarts, while industries that have been around for a while tend to be set in their ways. By getting into a young market, new companies can ride the growth of the market as more customers adopt their new products.
  4. “Market structure” – Study the characteristics of your new market. You have a better chance if you enter an industry that is labor-intensive, not capital-intensive. Avoid industries that rely heavily on advertising, because you’ll be at a disadvantage. Watch out for industries that are highly concentrated between just a few major players; entry will be very difficult. Also, look for industries where the participating companies, on average size, are relatively small. This suggests that the economic forces are conducive to small firms, obviously an advantage for start-ups.

“The central goal of this book is to provide you, as a potential or actual technology entrepreneur, with the tools necessary to identify the right business concept.”

Rule No. 2: “Identify Valuable Opportunities”

Being an entrepreneur calls for taking advantage of opportunities when they arise. Be mindful of the types of opportunities likely to come your way. Technological change is perhaps the most obvious opportunity, but there are others. Changes in society generally, including demographic changes, present many opportunities. Some opportunities stem from new regulations and political shifts, or from industries that evolve constantly. Shrewd entrepreneurs exploit those shifts to their advantage – think of how Jeff Bezos and Amazon.com took advantage of the Internet to reinvigorate book selling.

Once you perceive an opportunity, match it to the type of innovation you will use. Certain industries are much more receptive to some types of innovation, such as enhancing the scale of production, increasing production process automation, improving yields or boosting performance. Some opportunities transcend new products, including innovative forms of organization or new production processes. To improve your likelihood of finding new entrepreneurial opportunities gather and process as much information as possible about your targeted industry and the changes affecting it.

“While it wouldn’t hurt to be a good entrepreneur no matter what business you start, what really matters is picking the right business for a start-up.”

Rule No. 3: “Manage Technological Evolution”

Technological evolution doesn’t happen randomly. To succeed, study its patterns. They may open entrepreneurial doors at specific points in the process.

“New firms tend to perform better when industries are first born, or are young and growing, than when they are mature or are dying out.”

Perhaps the most important pattern to understand is the “shifting technology S-curve.” Richard Foster, a McKinsey & Company consultant, developed the S-curve to depict the rate of adoption of any given technology. Graphically, at the bottom of the S, you have a very low adoption rate. At some point, adoption takes off and climbs. As the industry matures at the top of the “S,” the adoption begins to plateau. This curve tells the entrepreneur several important things. First, initial acceptance will be low as you compete against established alternatives. Don’t expect your product to be in high demand right away. Often the best time to enter an industry with a new product is when established companies’ products are at the upper end of the plateau and leveling off. At that point, customers are getting restless for a better mousetrap just as larger competitors are focused on squeezing diminishing returns out of their current technology, where they have investments they cannot abandon.

Study product designs in your industry, and observe how they influence the structure of markets. Technical standards, such as the establishment of a CDMA standard for cellular telephones, can be very influential. Entrepreneurial entry will be more favorable before any one design starts to dominate the market.

“Much like the typical lottery ticket buyer who dreams of being the jackpot winner, but ends up holding a handful of losing tickets, the typical entrepreneurial effort ends in a business closure.”

Rule No. 4: “Identify and Satisfy Real Market Needs”

It sounds obvious, but to succeed you need to address real customer needs. Focus groups and surveys can help you determine what consumers really want, but they usually aren’t the whole answer. Your innovations must focus on solving real problems, preferably economic ones.

“The process of developing a new technology company involves the management of significant uncertainty.”

Rule No. 5: “Understand Customer Adoption”

Consumers adopt new ideas and products based on a curve that moves slowly at first, and then with increasing rapidity. While you ultimately want to satisfy your industry’s mainstream customer base, you may find that you can enter the industry more smoothly by creating products and services that appeal to a targeted piece of the market. This provides a base for making the transition to serving the broader market.

When estimating the potential size of your market, consider its dynamics rather than relying on a static snapshot. Study evolving “technology diffusion and substitution.” Diffusion measures how quickly consumers adopt a given technology-based product or service. An accurate diffusion estimate will tell you how big the market will be. Substitution occurs when consumers replace one product or technology with another. Classic examples include the substitution of Internet telephone service for standard telephone service, and the substitution of digital cameras for film-based technology. Substitution tends to negate the “scale economies” of larger competitors. It provides fertile ground for the entrepreneur.

“When a new product is introduced, a small number of customers, called innovators, adopt it immediately.”

Rule No. 6: “Exploit Established Company Weaknesses”

When battling Goliath, it’s better to strike at his weakness rather than his strength. Exploit the weaknesses of the established companies in your market; don’t go up against the things they do best. Established firms, for example, often fixate on the efficiency of their existing operations. You may beat them on innovation, but if you try to out muscle their distribution network, they may crush you. Established companies are weighed down by the need to keep their existing customer base happy. As an entrepreneur, you’re free to invest in any product you want to offer.

“Established companies need to reward people for doing their existing jobs, and this constrains them from rewarding people for undertaking innovation.”

Rule No. 7: “Manage Intellectual Property”

Large companies sometimes let others innovate, then come in and imitate their successes. You can thwart or, at least, delay this process two ways. The first is to maintain the confidentiality of your innovations and processes for as long as possible. For example, limit the number of individuals who have access to proprietary information, and preserve the information in a form that is tacit rather than written.

The second technique is patenting, a critical tool for preserving your firm’s intellectual property. Patents give you the time to assemble a system of vendors and distributors to bring your product to market. Yet, patents carry some serious disadvantages. Defending a patent can be very expensive, especially if you’re up against a phalanx of opposing corporate attorneys. When you obtain a patent, you must explain how your new technology works; this itself can diminish the value of the patent. And patents don’t work well in industries where competitors can attain the same objective easily with alternative technical means.

“While entrepreneurs like to think of themselves as being able to overcome all of the obstacles that life puts in front of them, being a successful technology entrepreneur is really more about playing the odds successfully.”

Rule No. 8: “Appropriating the Returns” for Innovation

Proactively creating barriers to copycat firms is always a good idea. Companies that are prepared to do so have a much better chance of thriving. Traditional methods of creating barriers, such as building a brand-name reputation, may not be available to entrepreneurs, but some other tactics are, though not all of them work in every circumstance. To raise the barrier to imitation, perhaps you can gain control over the talent or resources needed to make your product. Or, maybe you can establish a unique, strong reputation and brand, since innovators often gain a first-mover advantage. Another aggressive tactic is to secure assets that complement your innovation, such as distribution outlets.

“Being a successful entrepreneur is much like being a good professional gambler. If you know the games where the odds are least stacked in favor of the house, and you understand the rules of the game you are playing, you can greatly improve your chances of winning.”

Rule No. 9: “Choosing the Right Organizational Form”

Entrepreneurs usually err when they try to own and manage all aspects of their value chain. Instead, you can advance your interests through contractual vehicles that harness other people’s efforts. These include licensing technology, franchising and corporate partnerships. Sometimes it is to your benefit to control rather than to own. Consider alternatives to outright ownership, for example, if you need to move quickly, but aren’t in a position to do so, or if a process requires capital you don’t have readily available.

Rule No. 10: “Managing Risk and Uncertainty”

Managing risk, or exporting it to other parties who can manage it better, is practically an art form. Certainly, some risk is unavoidable. However, you can manage and minimize the risks you face by taking these steps. First, gather as much information as possible before you make decisions that might raise your new firm’s risk profile. Try to minimize your investment in assets, especially if you won’t be able to recoup your investment if your venture fails. Don’t maintain a death grip on an approach that isn’t working – be willing to change your company’s direction quickly if new opportunities arise.

About pourya

I am an entrepreneurship postdoctoral research fellow at Tilburg University in the Netherlands. My vision is to fill the gap between entrepreneurship research and practice with this website. Research and practice are two separate islands when it comes particularly to entrepreneurship. There are hundreds of papers/articles written every month but we hardly see their contribution to real life entrepreneurship.

0 comments on “My take-aways from the book “Finding Fertile Ground” by Scott Shane

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: